 (Larger Image)
|
The Burglar on the Prowl
Product Group: Book
Publisher: No Exit Press (2004-12)
ISBN: 184243117X
EAN: 9781842431177
Dewy Decimal #: 813
Board book: 320 pages
|
Customer Reviews
|
Hit and Miss
Rating (3)
Date: 2007-08-27
3 out of 4 customers found this reveiw helpful
My second Bernie Rhodenbarr mystery, and quite a disappointing one, I have to say. This one suffers from the same problem as the first one I read (Burglar in the Closet) Rhodenbarr doesn't logically discover the clues he needs to solve the crime, as is conventional in a whodunnit. Rather, we have various set pieces in which Rhodenbarr admittedly does a lot of legwork, and then a conclusion where he simply guesses what happened...and gets it right. What connections there are, I find, are tenuous at best. Although there may be a connection between, say, people, it takes a leap of faith to connect them in the first place.
People buy whodunits because the implicit promise is that the reader will have access to the same information as the detective and try and work out the solution at the same time. The skill of the writer comes in where the hero works it out before the reader. In Rhodenbarr's world, he speaks to a lot of people, and then cobbles a long and convoluted theory together...which just happens to be the right one. Indeed, by the burglar's own admission, many of his conclusions are pure guesswork and conjecture. In this particular volume, he admits that there are many coincidences at work...which should set alarm bells ringing. Any writer that relies on the existence of conclusions, especially the half dozen or so in this novel, leaves himself open to accusations of poor plotting. Indeed, this book smacks of Block writing it `ad hoc' and getting a bit lost...then having to resort to cobbling together a narrative at the end which tells us what happened.
I like Block's gentle humour in these novels, but I'm finding them unsatisfactory in terms of the whodunnit plots. It simply doesn't have the "aaah, yeah!" factor that Christie's work, for example, has - the logical placing of clues so that the denoument is inevitable and you, the reader, should have seen coming.
|
|
entertaining, witty, light reading
Rating (4)
Date: 2006-04-04
I'm a Block fan and this book didn't disappoint. Bernie Rhodenbarr is likeable and funny, and the plot is another one of Block's 'unputdownables'. Good stuff.
|
|
Burglar on the Downhill Slope
Rating (2)
Date: 2005-08-05
4 out of 4 customers found this reveiw helpful
After reading Burglar in the Library and Burglar in the Rye, I was all set to start filling my bookshelves with Bernie Rhodenbarr adventures. Giddy with glee at receiving the latest Burglar on the Prowl, I took it on holiday to lap up, poolside and immerse myself in the fun and frolics. Unfortunately, I couldn't have been more disappointed. The plot was not only thin and far-reaching but Bernie seemed to be keeping so much of the info to himself, that he must have had a gang of invisible pixies doing the work for him. The usual quirky reparty between Bernie and Carolyn had mutated into the sort of slapstick banter that you expect a tap dancing number to follow, complete with waving hands. The story failed to sparkle and seemed to need a lucky dip of subplots to keep any interest alive. I closed the book a little bemused and alot more disappointed. From now on, I'll be reaching for the back catalogue for some vintage Bernie and leave the new adventures to mature.
|
|
A New Block Fan
Rating (5)
Date: 2004-07-05
This was my first ever Lawrence Block book and it certainly wont be the last! Its was fun, funny and easy to read. I loved the cast of charactors and Bernie would now be my favourite hero Cant wait to get my hands on more of this series!!
|
|
Bernie Bags the Baddies!!
Rating (4)
Date: 2004-06-18
2 out of 2 customers found this reveiw helpful
If you haven't met Lawrence Block's busy bookselling burglar, Bernie Rhodenbarr, you have ten treats ahead of you that include The Burglar on the Prowl. Bernie's addicted to burgling. He loves the feeling of being in someone else's place when they are not there, and he adores the loot that he lifts. But he has a conscience. He remembers being burgled himself, and avoids taking items of sentimental value to the owners. If he sees a wrong, he'll do what it takes to right it . . . even if there's nothing in it for old Bernie.Although it's usually best to start at the beginning of a series (in this case with Burglars Can't Be Choosers), Mr. Block does a good job of providing background in this story so you could begin with this one without losing very much enjoyment. The Burglar on the Prowl starts off innocently enough. Old friend Marty Gilmartin (the owner of the baseball cards that were stolen in The Burglar Who Traded Ted Williams) has a bone to pick with a fellow roué, plastic surgeon Crandall Rountree Mapes, who has seduced and alienated the affections of his girl friend. Never mind that both Gilmartin and Mapes are both married. Gilmartin wants vengeance. Gilmartin tells Bernie that Mapes keeps lots of cash in a wall safe at home and gives Bernie the address. Gilmartin is even willing to give up his usual finder's fee if Bernie will lift the loot. Bernie dutifully cases the joint, sees a way to pull off the caper, and heads home to watch Law and Order on television. Feeling twitchy, he decides to go out again. That impulse to go on the prowl sets off an incredible set of events that reverberate throughout the novel. After a lot of pondering, he decides he wants to burgle a brownstone . . . and wanders around until he finds one that calls out to him. Without casing the joint or knowing if anyone is at home, he breaks into a top floor apartment and finds some jewels and cash in the freezer. Then he hears two sets of footsteps coming up the stairs. He bolts for the window to the fire escape . . . and cannot open it. What next? Before the next few days are over, there are dead bodies all over New York and Bernie's been busted as a suspect in these cases. But he doesn't know anything about those bodies. Shaking off the inconvenience, there's still all of that loot at the Mapes place in Riverdale. Will Bernie glide away with it? These are just a few of the imponderables in The Burglar on the Prowl. Before he's done, Bernie finds a lot of baddies who need to be bashed . . . and Bernie does his best to be sure that happens. This book could have been subtitled "Meaningful Coincidences" and have understated the point. The plot creates astonishing connections among the characters that will leave you breathless by the end. Although it's all part of the fun of the book, if you are like me you'll find the plot overly complicated. Sometimes simple is better . . . and comic heist capers at some point lose their beauty with too many twists and turns. I graded the otherwise entertaining book down one star for the excesses in the plot. And the next time you get an urge to take a late night prowl, think of old Bernie in this book. Perhaps you'll decide to settle for a dish of ice cream at home instead.
|
|
Retail Price: £6.99
Amazon.com's Price:£0.01
That's 100% Off!
|
|